True Delta offers a thoughtful resource for car buyers. Publisher Michael Karesh has argued that his methodology for measuring vehicle reliability is more rigorous than what is used by Consumer Reports (Karesh, 2010). Certainly it is more detailed.
The website has a number of other useful features. These include an “ask an owner” section. Karesh has cultivated an intelligent and civil group of participants.
Karesh also publishes reviews of new cars. They strike me as being detailed, objective and well written.
How about sustainability data?
My main wish would be for more focus on sustainability issues. That could include data about a vehicle’s carbon footprint, the recyclability of components, and usage of nontoxic interior materials.
Also see ‘Healthy Stuff: Researching toxic chemicals in everyday products’
I grant you that this kind of information may hard to get. However, if the media pressed for it, over time it might become more readily available from automakers and government agencies.
Full access to True Delta’s features requires a membership. It looks like a worthwhile investment for those in the market for another car.
Not a substitute for Consumer Reports
All that said, I don’t see True Delta as a substitute for Consumer Reports. For one thing, Karesh only covers automobiles. In addition, Consumer Reports is unique among the auto media in not accepting ads, buying its own test cars and operating as a nonprofit.
I am not implying that Karesh is less objective than Consumer Reports. I have a lot of respect for his work. However, in the long run might True Delta be better able to live up to its ideals with a structure more like Consumer Reports?
True Delta | Facebook
- Free access to parts of the website; membership required for some services
RE:SOURCES
- Karesh, Michael; 2010. “2010 Consumer reports Survey Analysis: Part One: Insufficient Data.” The Truth About Cars. Posted Nov. 1.
Be the first to comment